I want to tell you about a 13-year-old. She lived in Concord, Massachusetts, and she and her whole family had huge hearts. They knew that there was a family in their community that was having a tough time around the holidays. This 13-year-old’s kind family packed up their things, they took them over, they took their presents, they took food, and they took care of this family that was really down on their luck. And three days later, This girl came down with a fever, sore throat, and rash. She spent the rest of her life suffering from the consequences of that fever, sore throat, and rash because she had scarlet fever.
The Unseen Lessons of Beth March: Why Strep Throat Is More Serious Than You Think
If you’ve ever read Little Women, you might remember the tragic story of Beth March, the gentle and kind-hearted sister who falls ill and never fully recovers. What you might not know is that her illness was caused by something as seemingly mundane as strep throat, which progressed to scarlet fever—a complication that, in her time, had no cure. Today, we have the tools to easily treat strep throat, but Beth’s story is an important reminder of why we shouldn’t take this common illness lightly.
Strep Throat: More Than Just a Sore Throat
In the developed world, strep throat is often seen as a minor inconvenience—an annoying reason to miss school or work for a few days. But this infection, caused by group A Streptococcus bacteria, can have serious consequences if left untreated. In Beth March’s era, before the advent of antibiotics, a simple sore throat could spiral into a life-threatening illness. Even today, complications from untreated strep throat can still occur, although they are rare.
Common Symptoms of Strep Throat:
Sore throat (often severe and sudden)
Fever
Red and swollen tonsils, sometimes with white patches or streaks of pus
Tiny red spots on the roof of the mouth
Swollen lymph nodes in the neck
Headache
Stomachache, especially in younger children
Rash (in some cases, which may indicate scarlet fever)
These symptoms can be mistaken for viral infections, which is why accurate diagnosis is crucial.
Why Accurate Diagnosis Matters
In Beth’s time, strep throat couldn’t be diagnosed quickly, and antibiotics were not available. Today, however, we have rapid tests that can diagnose strep throat within minutes. This is crucial because while strep throat can be easily treated with antibiotics, treating it without confirmation can lead to unnecessary complications.
Share
Two Types of Rapid Tests:
Definitive Rapid Test: This test gives a yes or no answer within minutes. If positive, antibiotics can be started immediately.
“Old School” Rapid Test: Fast results as well but not as sensitive so if the rapid test is negative but suspicion remains high, a throat culture should be done, which takes a day or two for results.
It's important to test for strep throat rather than just treating based on symptoms alone. Misdiagnosis can lead to improper treatment, such as giving antibiotics for a viral infection, which not only is ineffective but can also cause adverse reactions.
The Risks of Untreated Strep Throat
If strep throat is left untreated, the bacteria can cause a variety of serious complications. These include:
Scarlet Fever: Characterized by a red rash that feels like sandpaper, scarlet fever is essentially strep throat with a rash. It can lead to more severe illness if untreated.
Rheumatic Fever: This is an autoimmune response that can cause permanent damage to the heart, joints, and other tissues.
Peritonsillar Abscess: An untreated infection can lead to an abscess, which can block the airway and may require surgical drainage.
Unusual Complications Even With Treatment
Post-Streptococcal Glomerulonephritis: This is a kidney disease that can develop after a strep infection, regardless of whether it was treated.
Post-Streptococcal Arthritis: This is a condition of joint swelling and pain that can occur after strep throat. Usually, it resolves with anti-inflammatories and time.
PANDAS (Pediatric Autoimmune Neuropsychiatric Disorders Associated with Streptococcal Infections): This is a rare condition where children suddenly develop obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) or other psychiatric symptoms following a strep infection.
While these complications are rare, they highlight the importance of proper treatment and follow-up care.
Should You Consider a Tonsillectomy?
One common question parents ask is whether their child should have their tonsils removed to prevent recurring strep throat. While tonsillectomy may reduce the number of strep throat cases, it is not a guaranteed solution. Studies show that the benefits of tonsillectomy in reducing strep throat cases only last for about a year. Furthermore, the procedure itself carries risks, including a small but significant mortality rate.
Reasons to Avoid Tonsillectomy for Strep Throat:
Limited Long-Term Benefits: The reduction in strep throat cases is temporary.
Surgical Risks: Though rare, complications from surgery can be severe.
Recovery Time: The procedure requires significant recovery time, keeping children out of school and activities.
For most children, the risks of tonsillectomy outweigh the benefits when it comes to managing strep throat. Antibiotics are generally effective in treating the infection and preventing complications.
Returning to School After Strep Throat
A common concern for parents is when their child can return to school after being diagnosed with strep throat. The good news is that with effective treatment, children can often return to school much sooner than you might think.
Current Guidelines for Returning to School:
12 Hours After Starting Antibiotics: If your child starts antibiotics in the morning, they can often return to school the next day if they are feeling better and their fever has resolved.
Symptom Improvement: Ensure that symptoms like sore throat and fever have significantly improved before sending your child back to school.
This quick turnaround is a stark contrast to the prolonged illnesses of the past and showcases the power of modern medicine.
The Modern Miracle of Antibiotics
It’s incredible to think that the same illness that took Beth March’s life can now be treated with a simple course of antibiotics that costs less than $10. This bubblegum-flavored medicine is a far cry from the tragic outcomes of the past. However, it’s also a reminder of how important it is to recognize the symptoms of strep throat, seek a proper diagnosis, and ensure full treatment.
Key Takeaways for Parents:
Don’t ignore a sore throat, especially if it’s accompanied by fever or swollen lymph nodes.
Seek prompt medical attention to get a rapid strep test.
Complete the entire course of antibiotics, even if your child feels better after a few days.
Avoid rushing into a tonsillectomy unless absolutely necessary.
Strep throat may seem like a minor illness, but as the story of Beth March teaches us, it deserves our full attention and gratitude for how far we’ve come in such a tiny sliver of human history.
